Thus began the longest fought and closest presidential election in U.S. history. The House, under the Constitution, then chose between Jefferson and Burr for President. One time, in 1800, the U.S. Presidential Election resulted in a tie. But if it had been a tie, state law says that the winner would have … The elections of 1876, 1888, 1960 and 2000 were among the most contentious in American history. 1932 United States House of Representatives The election exposed a flaw in the Constitution, because the Electoral College was authorized to vote for two names for President. The 1800 presidential election further tested the presidential selection system when Jefferson and Aaron Burr, the Republican candidates for President and Vice President, tied at 73 electoral ballots each. The US presidential election is not decided by popular vote, but Garfield won the national popular vote by only 1,898 votes or 0.0213%. In the 2000 presidential election, Al Gore beat George W. Bush in New Mexico by just 366 votes. 1. Much as President Trump is doing now, backers of Hayes, the governor of Ohio, charged the election … 1824 Presidential Election: Jackson vs. Adams In America's 10th presidential election, none of the four major candidates won a majority, leaving the decision once more to … Why 'close-call' presidential elections are happening more often. 1908 United States presidential: Missouri: 0.09066%: 629: 347,203: William Howard Taft wins a comfortable first term but takes Missouri by fewer than a thousand votes. Voters would choose 2 candidates out of many; the one with the majority vote became President and the one in second place became Vice President. In 1800, the election system was slightly different. At the time, Thomas Jefferson was running against incumbent President John Adams. But the United States has certainly had its share of close elections, dating from the earliest days of the republic to recent history. This caused Thomas Jefferson and Aaron Burr to tie for first place, both gaining more votes than then-President John Adams. Read on for five of the strangest presidential elections in U.S. history. While it might seem hard to believe that there could ever be a tie in a presidential election, it did happen in the year 1800 between Thomas Jefferson and Aaron Burr. The 2016 campaign between Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton was the 13th closest in the country’s history with Trump losing the popular vote by 3 million but winning the electoral college 304-227. A history of contested presidential elections, from Samuel Tilden to Al …